送交者: miaocai 于 2006-1-18, 15:52:34:
I studied at the same school and heard some stories about 孙优贤. One of my friends is his former PhD student. My former professor worked in the same area as 孙优贤. I have to say he does not have good reputation at all. He has an image as Hunhun and politician.
My former professor told us 孙 claimed his achivement on paper manufacturing automation , but the truth is that those plants where 孙 installed his control system eventually removed his system and used other systems instead. But he wasted a lot lot of funding from 863 program for this .
My professor was very angry at this.
I guess the author of that article is not in the same area as 孙优贤,and might not have graduate study in control.
Ask any professor in control area to get opinion on him, or his students.
However, 吕勇哉教授 had much better reputation at ZJU, and I think even much better than Lu.
------------------------------------------
在举一个例子，浙江大学的孙优贤院士，他是工程院院士。当我在浙江大学
的时候，他那个时候还不是院士，但是我对他非常尊崇。他在化工自动化领域的
成就不是多少人可以比肩的。以他为首的浙江大学自动控制学科在世界上具有很
好的声誉，他带领的国家重点实验室做出了很多重要的成果。当时我在浙江大学
时候，就常常去化自听课，对他们的学术研究还是很了解的。当然他们那儿曾经
有一个更牛的学术泰斗级人物，就是吕勇哉教授，现在美国。其实吕教授的学术
水平更是世界级的水平（人家也在中国做出的呀），可惜人在美国，好像一直没
有在国内评院士，很可惜。