送交者: 桂铭 于 2005-4-01, 10:39:35:

Terri的父母兄妹要她活，那个“丈夫”应该把她还给他们。活活饿死一个并不是养不起或者没人养的人，尽管你可以认为植物人没有价值，可是对她的肉亲还是有价值的。

另外，为什么法院不肯判插回管子，有什么法理依据？哪位法律届网友能给说说？

• 什么是人道，各人看法可以很不一样 - 自如 (1303 bytes) 2005-4-01, 11:45:06
  • 澄清一点：我说的痴呆儿是指没有自身意识也没有可能再发展的 - 自如 (495 bytes) 2005-4-01, 14:11:12
  • 死者长已矣，生者常戚戚 - 桂铭 (194 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:18:46
    • because that's against Terri's wish - 匆匆过客 (332 bytes) 2005-4-01, 14:01:35
    • 如果这些人真正会承担起Terri以后的生活，这当然是可以的。 - 自如 (323 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:32:46
      • TERRI丈夫已经作了选择 - 桂铭 (85 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:38:01
        • 如果TERRI的丈夫清心寡欲，十年来只是勤勤恳恳的照顾 - 自如 (207 bytes) 2005-4-01, 13:28:57
    • 一个人是为自己活着的，不是为别人 - conner (0 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:23:59
      • “身不由己”，你听说过吧？ - 桂铭 (0 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:31:25
  • If the Child is crippled, 应该打掉? - boxer (163 bytes) 2005-4-01, 11:52:37
    • I say 痴呆儿，which refers to those whose mental development can never proceed - 自如 (344 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:02:45
      • If you are in a coma, are you conscious of yourself? - boxer (323 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:46:20
        • We are not really on the same page - 自如 (662 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:56:14
  • 那以前法西斯给残疾人绝育人道么 - xj (0 bytes) 2005-4-01, 11:52:11
    • 而且，我说的是当事人是否有权选择 - 自如 (32 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:22:22
    • 我说的是没有正常意识的痴呆儿或植物人，并不是指一般的残疾人 - 自如 (66 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:05:43
    • Shockley would like to provide money - boxer (143 bytes) 2005-4-01, 11:59:32
      • I misread you previously and thought you are saying that the guy - 自如 (0 bytes) 2005-4-01, 13:58:00
        • is paying to raise those kids - 自如 (220 bytes) 2005-4-01, 14:00:25
          • No, the difference is the definition of "death" - boxer (487 bytes) 2005-4-01, 14:29:28
            • It seems you never expect that there is painful dilemma in life. - mangolasi (1600 bytes) 2005-4-01, 14:56:54
              • You should know the context of my argument with 自如 - boxer (346 bytes) 2005-4-01, 15:17:00
                • If you are talking about Shockley case, I don't see anything wrong. - mangolasi (722 bytes) 2005-4-01, 15:37:19
                  • So interesting that you understand it this way - boxer (322 bytes) 2005-4-01, 16:07:01
                    • I don't see anything wrong w/ selling (one's own) and buying organs PER SE. - mangolasi (1506 bytes) 2005-4-01, 16:40:56
                      • Isn't it so? - boxer (269 bytes) 2005-4-01, 17:04:45
      • If someone has the money and wants to spend in this way, why shouldn't he? - 自如 (206 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:09:00
  • In no country 刚出生不久就发现孩子是痴呆的，应该打掉 - HunHunSheng (0 bytes) 2005-4-01, 11:49:05
    • Oh, in that case I mean if the parents shall have the option - 自如 (425 bytes) 2005-4-01, 11:58:22
      • a not is dropped in a sentence that makes the meaning reverse. :) - 自如 (127 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:17:35
• If you are in such situation that ..... - fair (294 bytes) 2005-4-01, 11:34:51
  • 这样的假说并不成立，因为那是突然发生的事故 - 桂铭 (39 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:12:13
• 靠机器饲喂一个停止思想的“人”有何人道可言 - 2Cul4U4 (78 bytes) 2005-4-01, 11:11:53
• After Cooling down - boxer (105 bytes) 2005-4-01, 10:58:45
  • 这个故事还是“血浓于水”的老生常谈 - 桂铭 (40 bytes) 2005-4-01, 12:33:57
• 我看早点安乐死更加人道 - conner (162 bytes) 2005-4-01, 10:49:20
  • 求生是本能吧 - 桂铭 (126 bytes) 2005-4-01, 11:00:56
    • 人，作为一种存在，最重要的是意识的存在。 - conner (120 bytes) 2005-4-01, 11:21:55
• Because Terri Schiavo did not want to live this way. - fair (23 bytes) 2005-4-01, 10:41:52
  • 好像只是那个丈夫“据说”而已，并没有任何证据啊 - 桂铭 (0 bytes) 2005-4-01, 10:54:57
    • That's why they went to Court and Court believed Husband. - fair (153 bytes) 2005-4-01, 11:28:40

加跟贴